We’re all for making daring makeup choices — especially if all it takes is switching up something small in your eye makeup routine, like mascara. And while foregoing the typical black formula might sound intimidating, colored mascara can actually be quite complementary if you choose a color that goes well with your natural eye color.

“Skip eyeshadow and pair an electric colored mascara with a tight-lined matching liner for a graphic bold statement,” suggests Lancôme National Makeup Artist Alex Sanchez. His tips for achieving the look flawlessly? “Be sure to prime lashes first to maximize the wear and color payoff of the mascara. And for a more subtle look, apply color on the top lashes and keep the bottom lashes bare.” Ahead, find the best colored mascaras that match your eye color.

Best Colored Mascara for Brown Eyes: Maybellin New York Snapscara in Black Cherry

Brown eyes look great with a mascara that offsets their naturally warm undertones. Reach for a mascara with a cool undertone to really make brown eyes pop. We love purple for this, which is why Black Cherry is a go-to. It’s a deep violet that’s super pigmented and will instantly lift and brighten brown eyes.